The Allan Hill region of Antarctica has produced the oldest ice core samples ever recovered, which provide insights into Earth’s climate history prior to the existing 800,000 year ice core record. However, the highly disturbed nature of this ice complicates straightforward dating and interpretation. Understanding the scales of preserved climate records in this old ice will enable deeper insights into the variability of climate over the last 2 million years. Here I study a section of ice from ALHIC1901, an ice core recovered from the Allan Hills in 2019. This section has three parallel sets of water isotope measurements, and they all show a small but significant dip. However, the cause of this dip remains unclear. The goal of this study is to test whether this isotope change could be a glacial-interglacial transition preserved for 1.3 million years, or whether diffusion should have eliminated any climate signal. To investigate this question, I apply a simple water isotope diffusion model that takes as inputs temperature, an initial water isotope profile, and a thinning history, and provides as an output the resulting water isotope profile after a given number of years. I identify the range of possible temperature, thinning, and initial water isotope signals for this ice. I use these as inputs for the diffusion model, and compare the results to the ice core record to evaluate if the observed water isotope signal can be climatically driven. Constraining the cause of this water isotope signal will improve our understanding of fine scale paleoclimate proxy changes in the extremely old Allan Hills ice cores, enabling new insights into past climate variability.