Early-stage melanoma, squamous and basal cell carcinomas have local control rates of >90% with wide excision after pathologically clear margins and >95% with Mohs micrographic surgery. Local control rates for these approaches are not well defined in Merkel cell carcinoma (MCC). Herein, we analyzed data from 80 patients (pts) in a Seattle-based IRB-approved registry who had local MCC and underwent surgical excision with pathologically clear margins. Patients who had local radiation therapy after surgery were excluded as radiation affects recurrence rate independent of surgery. We also performed meta-analysis of 13 published studies (846 pts) based on a random-effects model. For the 80 pt cohort, local recurrence rate (LRR; ≤2 cm from the primary tumor) was 10%. In-transit recurrence rate (ITR; >2cm from primary) was 1%. Regional nodal recurrence rate (RRR) was 5%. This cohort had low-risk characteristics with small primary tumors (74% were ≤1 cm, 23% were 1-2, and 4% were >2 cm). No residual tumor was found in 60% of re-excisions while 29% had closest pathologic margins <1 cm. Meta-analysis of 9 published studies (745 pts) who underwent excision with clear pathological margins yielded 16.4% LRR [95% CI 8.3-26.5], 9.5% ITR [95% CI 5.4-14.6], and 32.1% RRR [95% CI 19.1-46.7]. Data from 4 studies (101 pts) who underwent Mohs yielded 3.6% LRR [95% CI 0-16.3], 12.8% ITR [95% CI 6.4-21.1], and 20.7% RRR [95% CI 13.8-38.3]. In each cohort, LRR/IRR following surgical excision with pathologically clear margins was >10%. This suggests MCC is more likely to recur near the excision site than other skin cancers and may reflect biological difference in the MCC local extension pattern (discontinuous spread beyond pathologically clear margins). Even for pathologically negative excisions, higher risk tumors may benefit from adjuvant radiotherapy.