As one of the westernmost stratovolcanoes in the Trans-Mexican Volcanic Belt (TMVB), Ceboruco exhibits a wide range of compositions correlating to its variable eruption style. With around 55,000 people residing within 10 km to the vent, Ceboruco represents an important hazard. Magmatism in the Ceboruco region is the consequence of both compressional and extensional tectonic regimes: the small Rivera plate subducts under North America, and regional crustal extension promotes the formation of three intersecting grabens in western Mexico, one of which hosts Ceboruco. In this tectonic setting, compositions are variable, and types of eruption fluctuate between moderately-effusive ones, like Ceboruco’s 1870-5 CE event, to large Plinian activity, like its caldera-forming eruption 1,060 ± 55 yr BP. Historically documented, the 1870-5 CE eruption led to the formation of a 7.5 km long lava flow, a small plug dome, and a larger dome complex (El Escarabajo). All these lavas exhibit the same trachydacitic composition (~68 wt.% SiO2, ~9 wt.% Na2O+K2O), signaling that they were derived from the same magma batch. As the eruption sequence and the subsurface pre-eruptive conditions remain unexplored, I probe those processes using bulk and mineral compositional analyses, microtextural observations, and phase equilibrium modelling. Higher crystallinity and higher Ba abundance in the dome complex suggest its derivation from the denser, deeper portions of the magma body hinting that El Escarabajo erupted late in the 5-year period. Reverse zoning in plagioclases (An67-72) and Ca-depleted rims in clinopyroxenes indicate perturbation in Ceboruco’s magmatic system before the event. Phase equilibria modelling suggests re-equilibration of orthopyroxenes approximately in the upper 7 km during magma ascent. The compositional and textural variability indicate magma mixing, which is a common process leading to explosive activity in other TMVB volcanoes such as Popocatépetl and Volcán de Colima.