Gull species in the genus Larus differ in breeding range, habitat use, size, and feeding behavior. During their post-breeding season, however, many species of gulls gather and temporarily occupy the same sites and habitats. Although there is evidence of niche partitioning by gulls in northeastern North America and northwestern Europe, the mechanisms by which gulls coexist in the San Juan Islands of Washington state are poorly studied. To investigate gull coexistence on San Juan Island, WA, we studied the intertidal feeding ecology of Mew Gulls (Larus canus), California Gulls (L. californicus) and Glaucous-winged Gulls (L. glaucescens). Patterns in abundance, behavior, substratum-use, and large prey type (identifiable through spotting scope) were investigated through observational methods at Jackson Beach. Pairwise chi-square tests revealed significant differences in large prey type and substratum use between California and Mew gulls and between California and Glaucous-winged gulls. Patterns in frequency of large prey captured illustrate differences in prey selection among species, with Mew gulls capturing primarily worms, California gulls capturing primarily fish, and Glaucous-winged gulls demonstrating generalist foraging behavior. These findings suggest that during foraging, the gull species use shared habitat differently by specializing in different large prey types. This supports previous evidence of niche partitioning among gulls, and suggests that niche partitioning reduces competition among gull species in the San Juan Islands.