In the United States, Major Depressive Disorder and Generalized Anxiety Disorder are among the most prevalent of mental health disorders. There are, however, disparities in the prevalence of depression and anxiety between racial and ethnic groups. Generally, whites have higher rates of depression and anxiety than blacks, but blacks have a higher rate of persistent depression than whites. One potential factor relevant to this disparity in depression and anxiety rates is ethnic identity. This study therefore sought to investigate how ethnic identity predicts depression and anxiety differentially between blacks and whites. Based on past literature, we hypothesized that higher ethnic identity would predict lower depression and anxiety in blacks, in that having a strong black identity would inoculate individuals from the harmful and depressogenic effects of discrimination, a known risk for depression in blacks. We hypothesized that ethnic identity would have no effect in whites. The study recruited black (n=54) and white (n=64) participants from Amazon Mechanical Turk to complete a battery of self-report questionnaires including measures of ethnic identity, depression, and anxiety. A linear regression analysis was computed predicting depression and anxiety from measures of ethnic identity, with race as a moderator variable. Results indicated that higher ethnic identity had no significant effect on depression and anxiety in whites, but predicted higher depression and anxiety in blacks. Therefore our hypothesis was not supported. These data contradict previous findings that strong ethnic identity can be a protective factor against depression and anxiety. It is possible that, in today’s political climate of increased white nationalism and violence against blacks, ethnic identity may in fact be becoming a risk factor. Future studies would explore how ethnic identity corresponds to heightened sensitivity to discrimination, thereby predicting higher depression and anxiety in blacks.