Herbivorous fishes feed on stems, leaves, flowers, seeds, fruits, and nuts of diverse aquatic plants, as well as algae. In the Neotropics, many of these fishes have intricately tied ecologies with their prey plant’s life history and facilitate seed dispersal; including the herbivorous cousins of piranhas, pacus. Most pacus experience fluctuation in their diet that reflects the changes in seasonality and plant part availability. A few species of pacus, however, exhibit a specialized feeding strategy known as phytophagy; solely consuming the plant material of Podostemaceae (riverweed). This trend of dietary specialization may be paralleled by a similar shift, away from general herbivory, and towards a specialized phytophage morphology. To investigate the link between diet and morphology within the greater scope of herbivory, we examined four coexisting species including: the seemingly specialized phytophage, Ossubtus xinguense; the generalized phytophages, Tometes kranponhah and Tometes ancylorhynchus; and a facultative phytophage, Myloplus rhomboidalis. We compared the gross morphology of these species with several other serrasalmids using micro-computed tomography scanning to measure functional jaw characteristics, as well as using geometric morphometrics to compare body shapes. Jaw biomechanics indicate that O. xinguense produces the weakest jaw leverage potentially as a result of its sub-terminal mouth. However, we also concluded that the phytophagous species as a group, do not overtly differ from the more generalized herbivorous pacus in terms of jaw mechanics (but remain distinct from the piscivorous piranhas). Body shape analyses also show little divergence among phytophage and herbivore body shapes, suggesting that many herbivores share a similar bauplan adapted for fast flowing waters. With the exception of O. xinguense, phytophagous pacus appear to be equipped with a general herbivory feeding morphology sufficient for a specialized diet. This suggests that phytophagy is not a particularly challenging feeding strategy, but performance may be augmented by additional morphological specialization.