Knowing the age structure of a population improves demographic models, but birds lack many structures, such as teeth and otoliths, used to age other animals. Marking and following large numbers of individuals is required to know the age structure of a penguin population beyond the distinction between juvenile and adult plumage. In a large population of Magellanic penguins (Spheniscus magellanicus) at Punta Tombo, Argentina, we coded eye and foot color. The penguins ranged from less than one year to more than 28 years of age. We examined iris pattern and color, defining “distinct” eyes as reddish-colored irises with concentric red and pink rings and “indistinct” eyes as dark-brown irises. More than 75% of 2-3 year-old Magellanic penguins had distinct eyes, compared to 50-75% of 4-6 year-olds, 25-50% of 7-20 year olds, 10-25% of 21-24 year olds, and <10% of 25+ year olds (n=3262). Foot color progressed from mostly white to mottled to mostly black. We also examined foot color in a small known-age zoo population of Humboldt penguins (Spheniscus humboldti). In Humboldt penguins, feet became mostly black within a year of hatching, but continued to darken slowly with age (n=44, maximum age=25 years). In Magellanic penguins, feet took several years to become mostly black (n=190). Nestlings had mostly white feet with small specks of black (n=16). About 88% of adults 3-11 years old had mottled or mostly black feet, while the remaining 12% had white or fully black feet (n=90). 24 of 25 adults 23 years or older had black or almost black feet. Individual variation in both eyes and feet prevents aging an individual with a high degree of certainty, but a population may be split into broad adult age classes based on eye and foot color.