I focus on the ongoing effects produced by the Dayton Peace Agreement in Bosnia-Herzegovina. I explore areas this agreement failed to address and how these failures have resulted in new discriminatory practices and prolonged the process of reconciliation. Through a provision in the Dayton Peace Agreement, the Bosnian government justifies the establishment of segregated schools, separating two of the most antagonist populations, Bosniak (Muslim) and Serb (Orthodox Christian) students. I analyze the conditions for ethnic discrimination produced by conflicting narratives in ninth grade history textbooks. Furthermore, with questionnaires that I sent out to individuals who have attended homogeneous schools, I examine whether history textbooks serve as a legitimate representation of collective memory. I elucidate how variation in the historical narrative may disparately affect Bosniaks and Serbs and the possibility of reconciliation through the assignment and internalization of “us” and “the other”. Through an analysis of ninth grade history textbooks, I argue that the lack of a consistent narrative alongside competing historical accounts hinder Bosnia- Herzegovina’s internal peace and reconciliation process.