It is well documented that women’s bodies face multiple forms of trauma. In the United States, for example, eating disorders affect nearly 10% of the female population and account for the highest mortality rate of any mental illness. Additionally, between 20% and 48% of women who have given birth describe the experience as traumatic. Previous studies of risk factors for intrapartum trauma and eating disorder etiology identify similar risk factors for both experiences, such as negative interpersonal relationships, lack of communication and emotional support, loneliness, powerlessness, perceived or actual loss of control, and heightened vulnerability. However, despite uniformity in conditions provoking distress related to these two experiences, the experience of having an eating disorder and of giving birth have never been compared as the purpose of any study. Because of this research gap, it is likely that many women may be significantly underserved in birth. By using a framework that engages theories regarding distress, healing, rites of passage, performance, embodiment, and feminism as they intersect in bodies at birth, this research explores how women with histories of disordered eating experience pregnancy, birth, and postpartum. Eight semi-structured oral life history interviews were conducted with women who were given clay and asked to sculpt their bodies at key moments during their life history. The life history of the researcher was also analyzed alongside the life histories of the participants in order to more holistically understand the ways in which sufferers of eating disorders experience distress and processes of healing. Analysis of the life histories and body sculptures reveals connections between the ways in which eating disorders and reproduction are experienced. This research demonstrates that while pregnancy, childbirth, and the postpartum period have the potential to propel women into suffering related to disordered eating, these experiences also hold the potential for healing.