Urban restoration is a burgeoning movement in our increasingly urbanized but ecologically degraded living places. The success of an urban restoration project is usually measured against only ecological principles, such as complex vegetation structure, increasing biodiversity, and improved ecosystem services. The narrow set of performance criteria ignores social factors contributing to successful urban restoration practice, which potentially hinders further improvements on urban restoration projects. The study aims to examine impacts of participants’ cultural awareness and availability of long-term stewardship resources, as two examples of social factors on the outcome of urban restoration projects and also to create representative social indicators that can be adopted in urban restoration evaluations. To understand these two social variables, I conducted surveys on restoration volunteers and interviews with project managers/volunteer coordinators of local restoration groups, as well as extensive literature reviews. My internship as the volunteer coordinator for the Kincaid Ravine restoration project also provided first-hand experience working with volunteers on urban forest restoration. Findings suggest that two factors of urban ecological restoration projects selected can affect the outcome of restoration projects through various means therefore need to be incorporated into restoration evaluations. My research serves as a case study of two specific social factors; further research on the impacts of other social variables on the outcome of urban restoration projects is required. Moreover, it lays the ground for further efforts in developing social indicators to evaluate urban restoration practice, which is a necessary step towards promoting comprehensive urban ecological restoration.