Egalitarianism is a central value in the United States, with the strive for equal treatment for all individuals evident in law, policy, and education. In contrast, for East Asian cultures, which are deeply rooted in Confucianism, the existence of social hierarchy is seen as natural and justified, and more value is placed on harmoniously maintaining it than it is for achieving social equality. As biculturals, immigrants from East Asian cultures are socialized into both sets of norms, values, and behaviors, and can identify with both cultures. Given such incompatible values surrounding equality, how might experiencing discrimination affect feelings of conflict in an Asian immigrant's bicultural identity? In Study 1, first-generation Asian females completed scales of perceived sexism in the United States as well as the Bicultural Identity Integration Scale, a measure assessing the degree of compatibility a bicultural finds between their two identities. Results showed that the more participants perceived personally being a victim of sexism in the United States, the more conflict they felt between their two identities, even after controlling for perceptions of immigrant-related discrimination. In Study 2, female Asian immigrants were exposed to a scenario in which they anticipated receiving a grade that did or did not stem from sexism. Consistent with hypotheses, participants who considered experiencing sexism reported more cultural conflict between their Asian and American identities compared to participants who did not consider sexism. Together, these studies raise the possibility that differing cultural values placed on egalitarianism can create feelings of identity conflict for immigrants when they face discrimination.