Since its formation as a genre in the 1960’s, Dominican bachata music has been associated with the poorest, blackest sectors of Dominican society, particularly rural migrants who brought the music from the country to the city. Recently, however, young Dominican music groups in New York City, most famously Aventura, have popularized the genre and turned it into a symbol of Dominican national pride. Some have argued that Dominican migration to North American cities, particularly New York, has led to a change in postcolonial racial attitudes in the Dominican Republic and an increased sense of black consciousness and pride. While the change in attitudes towards bachata music might initially suggest this trend, this paper argues that Aventura’s bachata articulates traditional racist ideas of Dominican nationalism that have circulated since the founding of the nation in the 19th century and reveal the nation’s colonial legacy. In particular, articulations of machismo and modernity in the music echo longstanding white supremacist ideals, which emphasize Spanish heritage and attempt to disguise or deny African traditions. Rather than breeding a sense of black consciousness among Dominicans, migration has provided another forum for Dominicans to symbolically whiten themselves and the nation through an emphasis on traditional patriarchal values and Euro-centric ideas of modernity and progress. The analysis draws on interviews with young adults in the Dominican Republic concerning Dominican music and migration, lyrics from popular Aventura songs, and Internet discussion posts about Aventura’s music. By examining discussions of modernity, family values and gender relations, the paper demonstrates how Dominican nationalism articulated by Aventura reinforces historic ideas of racism and exclusion in the Dominican Republic in new, transnational spaces.