Nigerian playwright Wole Soyinka writes that Yoruba narratives share elements with early Greek narratives but differ from Greek literature in their conceptions of divine authority. While Yoruba deities, who like Greek tragic heroes are beset with fatal flaws, must atone for these flaws through moral retribution, Soyinka argues Greek deities have no conception of moral responsibility, fearing only the threat of retribution from divinities more powerful than themselves. My research presents an alternate view, that the corollary within traditional Yoruba culture to Greek and later Roman Classical cultures is not a correspondence of gods to gods, but of gods to deified men. While in Yoruba culture gods undergo a process of death and rebirth, described by Jung as individuation, Classical Western heroes are often human beings claiming either divine parentage or divine authority. Though they claim their power and destiny from the gods, these heroes are not themselves gods, though many do undergo post-mortem apotheosis and are thereafter included in the Greek or Roman pantheon. Soyinka argues that, because Jung distinguishes between “primitive” (i.e. African) and “civilized” (i.e. Greek and Roman) cultures, Jung’s conception of the collective unconscious is undermined. I posit that the process of individuation is present and that the themes of death and rebirth are common to Yoruba and both Greek and Roman cultures. By contrasting two iconic figures, Vergil’s Aeneas, the mythological founder of Rome, and Obotunde Ijimere’s Obtala, the Yoruba creator of man, my analysis will highlight how understanding these mythologies, Greek/Roman and Yoruba, and the points at which they intersect and diverge, will provide insights into how the hero mythologies of these two cultures have universal themes, allowing audiences of divergent heritages to appreciate their respective rich literary traditions.